Zum Hauptinhalt wechseln

Apples 2016 Überarbeitung, ihres auf professionelle Benutzer ausgelegten Laptop Lineups. Es ist ausgestattet mit einem 15 Zoll 2880 x1800 Retina Display, einem quad-core Intel Core i7, mit 256GB / 512GB / 1TB / 2TB Speicherplatzoptionen, 16 GB RAM Arbeitsspeicher und einer Tastatur mit einer Touch Bar. Es erschien im November 2016. Modell: A1707.

127 Fragen Alle anzeigen

MacBook Pro constantly thinks its lid is closed?

Hi there,

Ive worked for years on component level repair logic boards etc but this problem has me stumped, the machine switches on but then instantly acts as if the lid has been shut therefore going into sleep mode, the only way I can get the device to work is buy running it in clamshell mode then installing insomnia (if you haven't heard its a program that can prevent your Mac sleeping with the lid closed). I couldn't find an issue with the logic board but I again tested it with a known working one. but still nothing. then I thought they may be sensors etc in the screen so I changed that too but still nothing. What else is there ? I'm stumped. I might also add there is no sign of water damage and the machine passes diagnostics in clamshell mode.

Beantwortet! View the answer Ich habe das gleiche Problem

Ist dies eine gute Frage?

Bewertung 2
Einen Kommentar hinzufügen

4 Antworten

Gewählte Lösung

eventually fixed this by replacing the trackpad .... very weird

War diese Antwort hilfreich?

Bewertung 1

Kommentare:

These models only activate the trackpad (allowing it to move and click) when the LID_OPEN signal goes to the trackpad; this signal is activated when both the left and right hall effect sensors detect the magnet from the screen lid (a new feature to prevent magnets accidentally setting the screen off, since old models just had one hall effect sensor).

Your trackpad likely had a small amount of corrosion which was shorting LID_OPEN to ground, which would disable the signal and turn the screen off. Something to look out for in future :)

von

sounds great I can only assume it was the trackpad. good to keep in mind as I could've ended up spending a lot of money lucky for me I had the parts to test it .

von

Einen Kommentar hinzufügen
Hilfreichste Antwort

You'll need to do some sleuthing! You'll need a magnet and some steel paperclips. Hopefully you can get the system to alter its state.

Take the paperclips and slide it down on the inside surface of the lid around the side and top edges they should stick to the magnets that are located on the lid. Carefully, fold down the display so you can reference the location on the uppercase when the magnets hit. Now try your magnet sliding it on the uppercase when the clips where to see if you can find the Hall effect detectors location (a wax pencil marker might help). One of the magnet locations should cause the the display to turn off. In any case it will give you an idea where to look for the hall effect sensor within the system.

If you review the older Unibody 15" hard drive cable we can see the Hall sensor (marked in Red):

Block Image

So it can be well hidden! I've not serviced this system yet so I can't tell you were its hidden.

War diese Antwort hilfreich?

Bewertung 2

Kommentare:

Yeah I understand I've got plenty of cables I can find one. apart from a trackpad replacement and the repair of water damaged boards this is the first problem I've came across with that can be solved quick, I gave something similar to your idea stated above ago but the machine will not respond to anything the second the device is on, the lid thinks its closed I had a go at absoutly gutting the machine including the horribly adheared battery and can't find anything in the top case I'm going to take a look at the hinge mechanism as this is the only other place I can think, if it helps you to answer the problem the device still switches on automatically when the lid is opened which I thought it shouldn't do if there is a sensor faulty or something.

von

https://d3nevzfk7ii3be.cloudfront.net/ig...

Im going to take a look in this area too just incase its similar to the 12 inch

von

That would to a magnet! Not the sensor. The sensor needs to be wired back to the logic board. I wouldn't put it past Apple to do a switch-a-roo on us putting the sensor in the lid and the magnet in the uppercase! Does the location you marked appear to be a magnet?

von

Einen Kommentar hinzufügen

Hi all,

Am wondering if I'm looking at trackpad replacement also as I have same problem on a 13" MBP mid-2012 (A1278). Reece referred to "these models" and as Lewis' is from 2016 I'm not sure if mine is included in that family...?

Thanks for any help guys. I see trackpad cable is available on its own so might try changing that first.

Cheers, Sam.

War diese Antwort hilfreich?

Bewertung 0

Kommentare:

There is no lid sensor functionality through the trackpad on your model; the lid sensor is on the battery indicator. Unplug this and if the issue is resolved, it will be this. If not, it is related to the SMC_LID signal being pulled low on the logic board.

von

Thanks Reece, I replaced the trackpad this morning but it made no difference. Have just disconnected battery indicator cable as per your suggestion but also no effect, so guess I'm looking at replacing SMC on the board..? Not sure I'm up for a job like that but seems the only option...(?)

Cheers, for the tip anyway.

von

Dose the MacBook certainly go into sleep mode ? as this fault can be misinterpreted and instead be a backlight/display issue too

von

Thanks Lewis, I'm using it now so I don't think it goes into sleep mode (unless I tell it to), but no activity from trackpad, keyboard (after boot), or screen...

von

Einen Kommentar hinzufügen

hi all,

I have very similar issue, the only difference is that after SMC reset my Mac(late 16, 13”, Touch Bar) feels ok until I close the lid, it seems that there is no LID_OPEN signal. After SMC reset it works perfectly (sleeps, wakes up, turns on/off) until I close the lid. It happens in safe mode and after clear reinstallation of the system. Should I also try trackpad or start with hall sensors?

War diese Antwort hilfreich?

Bewertung 0
Einen Kommentar hinzufügen

Antwort hinzufügen

lewis Barker wird auf ewig dankbar sein.
Statistik anzeigen:

Letzten 24 Stunden: 7

Letzten 7 Tage: 38

Letzten 30 Tage: 226

Insgesamt: 3,280